Misleading Trade Terms vs. The Reality of Sapphire Origin
The use of trade terms like “Royal Blue” or “Cornflower Blue” in the sapphire market can be misleading when not backed by proper certification. However, the more problematic issue arises when origin itself is used as a proxy for color and quality, leading to confusion and potential misrepresentation.
Royal Blue Sapphire
Dakota 3.02 Carats Sapphire Oval Cut Gemstone Ring in 18k White Gold By Mike Nekta NYC
Cornflower Blue
6.46 Carat Oval Brilliant Cut No Heat Natural Blue Cornflower Sapphire
The Problem with Using Origin to Describe Color
One of the biggest misconceptions in the gemstone trade is assuming that a sapphire’s country of origin dictates its color or quality. While some origins have a historical reputation for producing exceptional stones, no single mine or country produces only top-tier sapphires. The reality is that:
• Every sapphire-producing region yields a range of qualities and colors.
• Only a small fraction of stones from any deposit actually match the high standards associated with origin-based trade terms.
• Sapphires from one location can exhibit color and clarity identical to stones from another, making visual identification unreliable.
For example:
• Kashmir Sapphires are famed for their velvety blue color and soft, glowing appearance, but not every sapphire from Kashmir fits this description.
• Burmese Sapphires are often described as having a deep royal blue with a slight purplish tint, yet Sri Lankan and even Madagascar sapphires can produce stones with the same look.
• Ceylon Sapphires are typically linked with lighter, more vibrant blues, but deep, rich blue Sri Lankan sapphires also exist.
This misconception isn’t just about marketing—it’s a direct consequence of how origin reports have influenced pricing. Some buyers will pay a premium for a lower-quality sapphire just because it has a desirable country of origin on its certificate, rather than evaluating the stone’s actual beauty.
Geographic Origin is an Opinion, Not an Exact Science
The gemstone industry wants absolute certainty in geographic origin determination, but science alone cannot provide it. As noted by GIA, origin identification relies not just on advanced testing methods but also on the expert judgment of highly experienced gemologists. The key challenges include:
• Overlapping characteristics – Sapphires from different countries often have similar chemical and inclusions profiles.
• Evolving mine conditions – A single deposit can produce different-looking sapphires over time.
• Discrepancies between labs – Major labs may issue conflicting origin reports for the same stone due to differences in testing methods and available reference samples.
Ultimately, geographic origin reports should be viewed as expert opinions, not absolute facts. When making a high-value sapphire purchase, a report is useful—but it should never be the sole deciding factor.
How to Shop for a Sapphire the Right Way
To avoid overpaying for a stone based on marketing terms, follow these guidelines:
✅ Look at the sapphire itself – Prioritize beauty, cut, and brilliance over a certificate.
✅ Request certification from a reputable lab – GIA, GRS, and Gübelin provide credible reports, and they do certify color terms like “Royal Blue” and “Cornflower Blue.”
✅ Understand that origin does not guarantee quality – A stunning Madagascar sapphire can outshine a mediocre Burmese one.
✅ Work with a trusted expert – A knowledgeable jeweler like myself can help you source the best sapphire for your budget, without getting caught up in marketing hype.
Looking for a Top-Tier Sapphire? Let’s Talk.
I specialize in sourcing certified, investment-grade sapphires at competitive prices. Whether you’re looking for an unheated Burma sapphire, a vivid Ceylon stone, or a rare Padparadscha, I can find the perfect gem for you.
📞 Call or text me at (212) 921-4647
🌍 Visit www.nektanewyork.com
Let’s find you a sapphire that’s truly worth the investment.